VAT and PAYE by Direct Debit: government plans a mandate from April 2029 as a safety net

After consulting, the government plans to require a VAT and PAYE Direct Debit mandate from April 2029, used only to collect bills unpaid at the due date.

The government dropped plans to make Direct Debit the required way to pay VAT and PAYE. Instead it plans that from April 2029 businesses would need a mandate in place, used to collect anything still unpaid at the due date. Not yet law.

Effective from
April 2029 (planned, not yet legislated)
Who it affects
VAT-registered businesses and employers who pay PAYE to HMRC

On 28 October 2026 HMRC published the government’s response to its consultation “Requiring payment of VAT and PAYE return liabilities by Direct Debit”. The consultation had proposed making Direct Debit the required way to pay VAT and PAYE. Having read the responses, the government has stepped back from that: businesses would keep paying however they like, but from April 2029 they would need a Direct Debit mandate in place, which HMRC would use to collect any VAT or PAYE return liability still unpaid at the due date.

This is a government plan announced in a consultation response, not law. The response does not include draft legislation, and it says the exemptions and the consequences for businesses that do not comply are still to be worked out with stakeholders (summary of responses, chapter 3).

What the consultation proposed

The consultation, announced at Autumn Budget 2025, opened on 23 June 2026 and closed in August 2026 (the consultation document gives a closing date of 16 August; the summary of responses says it closed on 18 August), so it no longer takes responses (consultation document, “Duration”; summary of responses, section 1.1). It asked about:

  • making Direct Debit the required method of paying VAT return and PAYE liabilities, subject to exceptions;
  • exceptions, including people who are excepted from filing VAT returns online (for example on grounds of religious belief, disability, age or remote location), businesses without a UK bank account, and payments above £20 million, the Bacs scheme limit on a single Direct Debit;
  • two ways to enforce it: a penalty for paying by any other method, which could apply even where the tax was paid in full and on time, or limiting today’s payment-deadline extensions (the PAYE 22nd-of-the-month electronic deadline and the VAT 7-day electronic extension) to Direct Debit payers only.

What the government decided

HMRC received 413 responses. 331 (80.2%) opposed mandating Direct Debit, 60 (14.5%) were neutral, 18 (4.3%) supported it and 4 (1.0%) gave different or qualified views for VAT and PAYE. Respondents’ main concerns were losing control over when money leaves the account and cash flow, payment authorisation controls in larger organisations, agents’ lack of visibility of what HMRC would collect, and trust in HMRC’s payment allocation systems (summary of responses, chapters 1 and 2).

In its response the government says:

  • businesses will still be able to pay a return liability using the current payment methods;
  • from April 2029, Direct Debit would be used “as a safeguard to collect any return liability which remains unpaid at the due date”;
  • businesses would be required to set up a Direct Debit instruction for VAT and PAYE return payments unless exempt;
  • the requirement would be reviewed if Direct Debit is superseded by another automated payment method before April 2029;
  • HMRC will use the time before April 2029 to work through which exemptions are needed, how to encourage early take-up, and “what the consequences will be of continued non-compliance with paying accurately and on time”, and to fix IT issues around payment allocation and review agent services.

The response does not adopt either enforcement option from the consultation. It does not set a penalty, and it does not change any payment deadline.

Time to Pay. Respondents warned that a Direct Debit could be collected before an agreed Time to Pay arrangement takes effect. The response does not set out how the two would interact; it says HMRC “already provides a flexible range of support for those who would like to pay on time but find it hard to do so” and will work with stakeholders on access to those arrangements. If you cannot pay a VAT or PAYE bill now, see our guide to setting up a Time to Pay arrangement.

Who it would affect

Every VAT-registered business and every employer paying PAYE, unless an exemption applies. HMRC says around 330,000 of roughly 2.7 million VAT and PAYE businesses already pay by Direct Debit (summary of responses, section 1.1). Businesses that pay on time by another method would, on the government’s plan, see no collection by Direct Debit: it is a backstop for amounts left unpaid.

How you pay VAT and PAYE now

Under the rules in place when this post was published (October 2026), Direct Debit is optional:

  • VAT. You can pay by Direct Debit set up in your VAT online account, by online bank transfer, or by debit or corporate credit card; personal credit cards are not accepted. Direct Debit is collected 3 working days after the payment deadline on your return and must be set up at least 3 working days before you submit the return. You cannot use Direct Debit for payments over £20 million, from an overseas bank account, as an insolvency practitioner, under a VAT payments on account arrangement, or if you are approved to send paper returns (GOV.UK: Pay your VAT bill). For most quarterly returns, payment is due one calendar month after the end of the period, with a further 7 days where the return is filed and the tax paid electronically (consultation document, chapter 4).
  • PAYE. The bill is due by the 22nd of the next tax month (or the 22nd after the quarter if you pay quarterly), or by the 19th if you pay by cheque through the post. A Direct Debit set up in your HMRC online account collects the amount on your Full Payment Submission, usually shortly after the 22nd, or 4 working days after you file if you file after the 19th (GOV.UK: Pay employers’ PAYE). Only employers with 250 or more employees are currently required to pay electronically (consultation document, chapter 5).

Late payment of either tax can bring interest and penalties now, whatever method you use; see our HMRC penalties guide.

What to do now

Nothing is required yet. The government says communications and guidance will give notice of what businesses need to do as the details are agreed. If you want the automation now, you can already set up a Direct Debit for VAT or PAYE. For VAT deadlines when you first register, see VAT registration thresholds and deadlines; for running payroll and paying HMRC as a new employer, see the PAYE and RTI employer guide.

Related guides

Use this calculator

Copy a citation linking back to this page. Attribution required under CC BY 4.0.

Plain text
 
HTML
 
Markdown
 

Paste an iframe into your blog or page. Free for any use; the embed shows a small "Powered by salarytax.uk" link.

Basic embed
<iframe
  src="https://salarytax.uk/embed/salary-calculator"
  width="100%"
  height="920"
  frameborder="0"
  loading="lazy"
  title="UK Salary Calculator by SalaryTax"
  style="border: 1px solid #e0e0e0; border-radius: 4px;"
></iframe>
Compact embed
<iframe
  src="https://salarytax.uk/embed/salary-calculator-compact"
  width="100%"
  height="380"
  frameborder="0"
  loading="lazy"
  title="UK Salary Calculator (compact) by SalaryTax"
  style="border: 1px solid #e0e0e0; border-radius: 4px; max-width: 560px;"
></iframe>

Full embed docs and live preview →